This gallery, in two parts, A: X-ray therapy and B: Gamma-ray therapy, was prepared by Colin Orton and Peter Almond based, in part, on their presentations at the History Committee Symposium presented at the 2013 AAPM Annual Meeting:
“Early x-ray therapy machines”
Because it was quickly realized that the new rays were causing skin damage to those handling the x-ray tubes and hence were, presumably, damaging skin cells, it was theorized that they might be able to kill cancer cells.
Within months, x rays began to be used to treat cancer.
On January 29, 1896, Emile Grubbé, a medical student in Chicago, who had established a small business making x-ray tubes, initiated a course of treatment on a Mrs. Rose Lee, who had breast cancer.
He delivered 18 daily “one-hour” treatments with the breast in contact with the x-ray tube.
Treatments were terminated when the patient developed excessive skin damage.
This patient died within one month due to systemic disease before local control could be studied.
This was common practice in the early years of x-ray therapy because:
It was not until 1914, after the development of the hot-cathode x-ray tube by William D. Coolidge, that the delivery of high, reproducible, doses became possible.
With the advent of the Coolidge x-ray tube came the quest for higher energy x-ray units in order to be able to treat deeper cancers with beams fired from multiple directions, thus reducing the risk of damage to normal tissues and organs surrounding the tumor.
X-ray machines with energies up to about 300 kVp began to be developed.
These were originally called “x-ray cannons” but, later, became known as “orthovoltage” x-ray units.
Between 1930 and 1934 several so-called “supervoltage” x-ray machines were developed in the USA, such as:
The World’s 1st 1,000 kVp machines were installed in 1933 at the Swedish Hospital, Seattle, WA, and at Caltech, Pasadena, CA.
The Caltech machine was in a vault 42 m long by 20 m wide by 15 m high.
The 9 m long x-ray tube protruded through the ceiling to the treatment room above.
A 1 MeV x-ray machine was installed at St. Bartholomew’s Hospital, London, in 1936 by Metropolitan Vickers engineer George Innes.
After installation, he was asked to stay on the staff in order to do measurements on the new machine and to maintain it.
George Innes, de facto, became the medical physicist in charge of the facility, although he was not a physicist by training.
He later became President of the UK Hospital Physicists Association and organized the 1st International Conference on Medical Physics, Harrogate, England in 1965.
In the late 1920s, Robert Van de Graaff was a Rhodes scholar at Oxford when he conceived the idea for an electrostatic particle accelerator capable of producing very high energies.
By 1931 he was able to produce a potential difference of 1.5 MV with a machine that cost $100 to build!!!
Van de Graaff had increased this to 7 MV by 1933
In 1937, Van de Graaff and John G. Trump (a founding member of the AAPM and uncle of President Donald Trump) installed the first Van de Graaff machine (1 MV air insulated) used for radiotherapy in Huntington Memorial Hospital, Boston.
In 1946, the High Voltage Engineering Corporation, founded by Van de Graaff, began commercial production of a 2-2.5 MV machine.
A total 40 Van de Graaff accelerators were built until their production was discontinued in 1959.
The quest for even higher energies continued with Donald Kerst, who built the world’s first magnetic induction accelerator at the University of Illinois in 1940.
The linear accelerator (linac) grew out of the development of the klystron and the magnetron for the generation of microwaves for radar during the 2nd World War by Russell & Sigurd Varian in Palo Alto, CA, and by Mark Oliphant in Birmingham, England.
In the USA, Henry Kaplan realized the potential of linacs for radiotherapy.
He worked with Edward Ginzton to design a medical linac and applied for an NIH grant to construct it, but it was disapproved.
In the UK, the British Atomic Energy Research Establishment designed a medical linac and contracted with the Metropolitan Vickers Electrical Company to build it.
The 1st therapy linac was an 8 MeV stationary machine built by Metropolitan Vickers and installed at Hammersmith Hospital, London, with the 1st patient treated on 19 August, 1953.
Edward Ginzton and Bill Hansen worked with the Varian brothers to build a 6 MeV linac, which was installed at Stanford University for Henry Kaplan.
The 1st patient, a 7-month old boy with retinoblastoma, was treated by Dr. Kaplan in January, 1956.
Henri Becquerel discovered radioactivity in 1896 and radium was discovered by Marie Curie in 1898.
The energy of the gamma rays from radium was about 1 MeV, meaning that they exhibited much better penetration than achieved with early x-ray machines.
Attempts were made between 1915 and 1950 to use these high-energy gamma rays for teletherapy using between 1 and 5 g of radium.
With such small amounts of radium available, the dose rates were so low that very short SSDs had to be used and inverse square law fall off of dose greatly reduced the useful depth of penetration.
Developed by Ernest Rock Carling, Stanford Cade and Frank Allchin in 1928.
The shutter mechanism was operated by a bicycle brake cable and it was typically operated at about 10 cm SSD.
The collimators on the Westminster Hospital were either 3.5 cm or 9 cm diameter.
Produced relatively sharply defined dose distribution.
Rapid fall off, however, due to short 10 cm SSD.
In order to use longer SSDs to improve the depth-dose distribution, Failla developed a 50 g Ra unit for the Roosevelt Hospital, Janeway Clinic for Therapeutic Radiology, New York, in 1950.
This was used at 25 cm SSD.
A similar unit was installed in Louvain, Belgium
In 1934, the French chemists Frédéric and Irène Joliot-Curie produced radioactivity artificially.
Because of the low specific activity, cost and poor availability of radium, only sources in the range 1-50g were possible, which required the use of short SSDs in order to keep treatment times reasonable.
These short SSDs resulted in poor depth-dose characteristics so, in a 1937 paper in Nature on Radium Beam Therapy and High Voltage X-Rays, A. S. Eve and L. G. Grimmett suggested, for the first time, replacing radium with a suitable artificially-produced radionuclide.
By the mid-1940s it began to be realized that the most suitable artificially-produced radionuclides would be Ir-192, Co-60 and Cs-137.
J.S. Mitchell, a physician/physicist from Cambridge and part of the British scientific contingent at the Atomic Energy Project in Chalk River, Ontario, Canada during and just after the war, had his physicist H. F. Freundlich design an Ir-192 teletherapy unit for him to use at the Radiotherapeutic Centre, Addenbrooke’s Hospital, Cambridge, England.
He treated his 1st patient in June, 1951.
In terms of output this was a good substitute for radium.
With a half-life of just 74 days, however, it required regular source changes and, with the source strengths available at the time, the SSD was just 8 cm, so the depth-dose characteristics were no better than for radium.
Also, with an average gamma-ray energy of about 400 keV compared to 1.2 MeV for Co-60 with its superior depth-dose, it is not surprising that such Ir-192 teletherapy units never caught on.
J.S. Mitchell was the first in print to suggest Co-60 teletherapy in a paper published in the British Journal of Radiology in 1946.
Others soon joined Mitchell in recommending Co-60, including
In the USA, in 1949 Fletcher, Grimmett, and R. Lee Clark, the director of M. D. Anderson, teamed with Marshall Brucer, the research chairman at the Oak Ridge Institute of Nuclear Studies (ORINS), in a joint venture to design and build a Co-60 unit.
Before the M. D. Anderson team could proceed, however, the AEC wanted a meeting in Washington D.C. in February 1950 to discuss all aspects of cobalt -60 teletherapy.
The meeting was convened February 13, 1950.
There were 33 attendees from the U.S. and Canada, half were radiologists, one third were physicists, and the remainder were from government agencies and industry from both countries.
It became evident from the meeting that two Co-60 teletherapy units were being constructed in Canada and that it would not be possible to activate a Co-60 source of sufficient specific activity at Oak Ridge for the M. D. Anderson machine and they would have to arrange for a source to be activated at Chalk River, in Canada.
Also, that construction of two Canadian units were well ahead of the Grimmett unit.
In June, 1950, three sources were inserted into the Chalk River reactor for activation, two for the Canadian Co-60 machines and the third for that to be installed at the M. D. Anderson.
In October 1950 Grimmett published “A 1,000 Curie Cobalt-60 Irradiator”, in the Texas Reports on Biology and Medicine, the first published paper on a practical Co-60 teletherapy unit.
Construction of the Grimmett-designed M. D. Anderson machine was completed in June, 1951 by General Electric X-Ray Corporation and shipped to Oak Ridge in August, 1951 for installation of the source.
The source, however, did not arrive at Oak Ridge until July, 1952. Too late! The Canadians were already treating patients on their Co-60 units by then.
Due to 14 months of testing at Oak Ridge, combined with delays in the construction of the building to house the unit, the first patient was not treated until February 24, 1954
Note: The first patient treated by Co-60 in the USA was at the Los Angeles Tumor Institute, April 23, 1952 on a home-made unit using multiple smaller Co-60 sources totaling 1080 Ci.
In Canada, the two sources activated at Chalk River had been commissioned by physicists Harold Johns, to install in a cobalt unit he had designed in the University of Saskatchewan, and Roy Errington and Don Green, to load into a machine designed and built by the Eldorado Mining and Refining Limited, Ottawa, to be installed at the Victoria Hospital, London, Ontario.
The sources were sent out between June and August, 1951.
The Saskatoon source was immediately installed in the Johns unit in August 1951, making this the 1st operational Co-60 machine.
Designed by R.F. Errington and D.T. Green, commissioning took less than a week for the Victoria Hospital Co-60 unit and they were able to treat their 1st patient on 27 October 1951, thus making their machine the 1st Co-60 unit to treat patients.
Over the ensuing 40 years, about 35 million cancer patients were treated with Co-60 teletherapy.
Atomic Energy of Canada Limited (AECL) took over production of the Eldorado Co-60 units and Johns sold his design for commercial production to Picker X Ray Corporation, Cleveland, Ohio.
In 1953, AECL introduced the 1st isocentric Co-60 unit, the Theratron.
General Electric declined the opportunity to commercialize the Grimmett unit.
For the next 30 years, the number of Co-60 units worldwide dominated the isocentric teletherapy scene until overtaken by linear accelerators.
In the early 1950s, Cs-137 began to be extracted from nuclear reactors as a fission fragment and sources suitable for teletherapy became available.
Cs-137 had one advantage over Co-60: its 30-year half-life.
Instead of having to change sources every five years with Co-60 units, they needed to be replaced every 30 years with Cs-137.
There were some disadvantages of Cs-137 teletherapy, however, and only about 400 Cs-137 teletherapy units were ever produced compared with about ten times that number of Co-60 machines.
Disadvantages of Cs-137 when compared with Co-60 included:
The Ir-192 and the Cs-137 units were replacements for the tele-radium units and were used at short SSD primarily for head and neck treatment, now much better treated on linacs.
Co-60 units were introduced as replacements for orthovoltage X-ray units and initially represented a significant improvement, but they are gradually being supplanted by higher-energy linacs with better physical characteristics.
In the USA, due to national security concerns about the number of high activity radioactive sources, Federal restrictions have been placed on the use of radioactive teletherapy treatment machines and they have almost all disappeared.
Perhaps the lasting legacy of cobalt-60 units is that the gamma rays became accepted as a standard beam of photons for calibration purposes.